The Penguins traded their top defense prospect, Calen Addison, to the Wild this week in the Jason Zucker trade.
For the record, I don't see much of an issue in the Penguins moving Addison. John Marino, another right-handed defenseman, isn't a "prospect" anymore, but he's only 22 (just three years older than Addison) and has already shown that he can stick in the NHL.
Addison will still need some time to develop in the AHL, and while I still expect him to play in the NHL someday, that's never a given. And even so, once Addison is ready for the NHL (which I'd anticipate being two seasons away at best), what are the Penguins likely to need more on the NHL roster? A scoring winger or a young, right-handed defenseman? Marino made Addison expendable.
Most of the intriguing defense prospects left in the system -- Pierre-Olivier Joseph, Niclas Almari, Clayton Phillips, John Nyberg -- are left-handed. The right-handed pool is pretty shallow. Let's take a look at the right-handed defensemen who remain in the system (pro, juniors, Europe, college, all of it) and rank them.
They have to be actual younger prospects (so, not someone like Zach Trotman) and have to either be on an NHL contract or a draft pick
1. WILLIAM REILLY
Reilly, 22, is in his senior season at RPI and will turn pro next season. Originally a seventh-round pick in 2017, Reilly already looks to be a steal of a pick. As a senior, Reilly is already one point shy of his career high with seven goals and 10 assists in 28 games. He quarterbacks RPI's top power play, leads all RPI defensemen in scoring, and ranks No. 2 overall in RPI in scoring.
At 6-feet-3 and 193-pounds, Reilly definitely has size. When he was drafted, the organization really pointed to his puck-moving abilities as a strength too.
“William Reilly is an offensive defenseman, has good size, he skates well,” said Randy Sexton, the Penguins director of amateur scouting at the time. “He moves the puck and he can really shoot the puck. We have some hope for him as a puck-moving, offensive defenseman.”
Since Reilly is still in college, he's still unsigned. I can't imagine the Penguins not wanting to sign him, but if he chooses to do so, he can hold out until Aug. 15 this summer and become an unrestricted free agent. But given the shallow pool, I don't anticipate Reilly trying to find a better situation for himself elsewhere. One might not exist.
2. SANTERI AIROLA
Airola, 19, was the latter of the Penguins' two seventh-round picks in the 2019 draft.
Airola is currently under contract with Kettera of Finland's second-tier Mestis league through next season with a club 2021-22 option, but it was reported last week that he is expected to sign with the Tampere Ilves of the Finnish Liiga, the top men’s league in Finland for next season.
Airola played in three Liiga games with SaiPa last season, and two games with SaiPa on loan this season. In his 26 games with Kettera this season, he’s recorded 11 assists.
Airola is on the smaller size at 5-feet-11 and 163-pounds.
“Airola was a guy that our European scouts were excited he was still available in the seventh round,” said Penguins director of amateur scouting Patrik Allvin. “He’s a late-bloomer. Skilled defenseman, a real good skater. That was a good flip to get him in the seventh.”
Airola won't be in the NHL, or even in North America anytime soon. The Penguins retain his signing rights until June 1, 2023, so he can stay in Finland through the 2022-23 season if he or the Penguins believe that is what is best for him.
____________________
That's it. That's the list. There are two. Every other defense prospect in college and Europe is a left-handed shot. They don't have any defensemen at all still in juniors after the Addison trade, and all the NHL-contracted defense prospects in Wilkes-Barre/Scranton are left-handed.
Here’s how the rest of the Penguins’ prospects in juniors, college, and Europe did this week:
____________________
FORWARDS
Judd Caulfield
Position: Forward
Size: 6-4/207
Shoots: Right
Drafted: 2019, fifth round
Team: North Dakota (NCAA)
Season totals: 23 games, 3 goals, 8 assists
Caulfield and North Dakota did not play this week.
Liam Gorman
Position: Center
Size: 6-3/196
Shoots: Left
Drafted: 2018, sixth round
Team: Princeton (NCAA)
Season totals: 23 games, 5 assists
Gorman recorded two assists in two games this week.
Filip Hallander
Position: Center/Wing
Size: 6-1/190
Shoots: Left
Drafted: 2018, second round
Team: Lulea HF (SHL)
Season totals: 14 games, 4 goal, 3 assists
Hallander was scoreless in one game this week.
Nathan Legare
Position: Right wing
Size: 6-0/205
Shoots: Right
Drafted: 2019, third round
Team: Baie-Comeau Drakkar (QMJHL)
Season totals: 48 games, 27 goals, 28 assists
Legare played in two games this week and scored one goal and three assists:
Two weeks ago he dropped the gloves:
Linus Olund
Position: Center
Size: 5-11/183
Shoots: Left
Drafted: 2017, fifth round
Team: Brynas IF (SHL)
Season totals: 37 games, 3 goals, 6 assists
Olund was scoreless in one game.
Nikita Pavlychev
Position: Center
Size: 6-8/225
Shoots: Left
Drafted: 2015, seventh round
Team: Penn State (NCAA)
Season totals: 23 games, 6 goal, 6 assists
Pavlychev was scoreless in two games.
Samuel Poulin
Position: Wing
Size: 6-1/207
Shoots: Left
Drafted: 2019, first round
Team: Sherbrooke Phoenix (QMJHL)
Season totals: 39 games, 30 goals, 38 assists
Poulin scored one goal and five assists in three games this week.
Valtteri Puustinen
Position: Wing
Size: 5-9/183
Shoots: Right
Drafted: 2019, seventh round
Team: HPK (Liiga)
Season totals: 42 games, 15 goals, 20 assists
Puustinen scored two goals in two games this week.
DEFENSEMEN
Santeri Airola
Size: 5-11/165
Shoots: Right
Drafted: 2019, seventh round
Team: SaiPa (Liiga), Kettera (Mestis)
Season totals: 2 games with SaiPa; 26 games, 11 assists with Kettera
Airola was scoreless in his only game this week.
Ryan Jones
Size: 6-2/186
Shoots: Left
Drafted: 2016, fourth round
Team: Nebraska-Omaha (NCAA)
Season totals: 30 games, 2 goals, 8 assists
Jones recorded one assist in two games.
Antti Palojarvi
Size: 6-1/172
Shoots: Left
Drafted: 2017, sixth round
Team: Lukko (Liiga), Lukko U20 (Jr. A SM-liiga), Hokki (Mestis)
Season totals: 5 games with Lukko; 14 games, 3 assists with Lukko U20; 19 games with Hokki
Palojarvi was scoreless in two games with Hokki.
Clayton Phillips
Size: 5-11/183
Shoots: Left
Drafted: 2017, third round
Team: Penn State (NCAA)
Season totals: 25 games, 2 goal, 7 assists
Phillips has been injured for the last two weeks and is considered day-to-day.
William Reilly
Size: 6-2/196
Shoots: Right
Drafted: 2017, seventh round
Team: Rensselaer Polytech (NCAA)
Season totals: 26 games, 7 goal, 10 assists
Reilly was scoreless in two games this week.
